Scheduling the M.Sc. Oral Exam
The supervisor and all supervisory committee members must approve the student’s thesis by signing the "Request to set up an M. Sc. Oral Examination" form (available on the Departmental web site). Supervisors are expected to read and return the thesis to their students within three weeks, after which the student will distribute a revised draft to the Supervisory Committee members. The Supervisory Committee members are expected to read and return the M.Sc. thesis with comments within two weeks. Failure of faculty members to meet these deadlines must be reported to the Graduate Coordinator as described below.
Upon completing the "Request to set up an M. Sc. Oral Examination" form, students must give at least 4 weeks' notice to the Student Services Assistant to schedule the M.Sc. thesis defence. It is the student's responsibility to distribute a copy of the thesis to each member of the Exam Committee at least two weeks prior to the exam. Failure to do so may result in rescheduling of the exam.
Choosing the M.Sc. Thesis Defence Exam Committee
The “Request to set up an M.Sc. Oral Examination” form includes a list of proposed Exam Committee members. The final composition of the committee is subject to the Graduate Coordinator’s approval. The Exam Committee is composed as follows:
- An Examination Committee member (voting member), will chair the Exam Committee. This member will be assigned to the exam based on the student’s primary field of interest as indicated on the form. The Examination Committee is expected to read the thesis and participate in the examination of the student.
- The student's Supervisor (voting member). The Supervisor may participate in the exam by asking questions and/or the discussion about the student.
- At least one Supervisory Committee member (voting member). Multiple committee members are welcome to attend the exam, but not required to do so.
- One ‘Arm’s-Length Examiner’ (voting member). This faculty member must hold a graduate appointment in SGS and may be from within the Department of Molecular Genetics or from another department. This examiner should have an arms-length relationship to both the student and the supervisor.
The Student Services Assistant is responsible for issuing a formal exam notice to all parties concerned. A copy of the notice is kept in the student's file and recorded on the database. As noted above, the student is responsible for the distribution of the thesis.
M.Sc. Exam Quorum
Quorum will be
- The Examination Committee Member
- One Supervisory committee member (other than the student’s supervisor); and
- The Arm’s-Length Examiner.
Delays in Scheduling the M.Sc. Oral Exam
If an oral exam is not scheduled within three months of the date permission was given to write a thesis and the "M.Sc. Terminal Committee Meeting Report" was signed, the student must submit an “Request to Extend the Time Limit for Completing the M.Sc. or Ph.D. Thesis” form (on the Departmental website), to the Graduate Coordinator. This request must include the following information:
- Which chapters have been written and approved by the supervisor(s)
- Which chapters are written but not yet approved Which chapters are incomplete and the reason(s) for this
- When the student expects to provide the supervisory committee with a complete draft of the thesis
- A realistic timeline for the oral exam
If the three-month deadline passes without an approved extension, the graduate stipend may be withdrawn due to failure to meet program requirements. HOWEVER, a supervisor may not withdraw a student’s stipend without prior consultation with the Graduate Coordinator. If a student has set up the exam within the required time frame, the stipend must be paid until both the oral exam and thesis revisions recommended by the Exam Committee have been completed.
Delays in Providing Feedback on the M.Sc. Thesis by the Committee
Since thesis writing and committee feedback must be completed within a tight time frame, supervisors and supervisory committee members are obliged to read and provide feedback on the draft thesis promptly. Supervisors are expected to read and return M.Sc. theses to their students in two weeks or less. Committee members are expected to read and return M.Sc. theses with comments in two weeks or less. If students do not receive the corrected thesis within these time frames, they should contact their supervisor or committee member by e-mail and obtain a revised deadline for finishing the corrections. If this subsequent deadline is unreasonable or if this deadline is not met, the student should report the situation to the Graduate Coordinator along with appropriate documentation. The Graduate Coordinator will take immediate measures to resolve the situation.
Thesis committee members sign the “Request to Schedule a M.Sc. Oral Examination” form only after they have read and critiqued the thesis. At that time, committee members will return the critiqued thesis and any additional suggestions for revisions. Students are expected to incorporate these changes before distributing the thesis to the External Examiner and other Exam Committee members. If there are disagreements between a committee member and the student and/or supervisor about the nature and/or extent of the changes to be made to the thesis, the Graduate Coordinator should be consulted. The Graduate Coordinator will decide on how to proceed. It is important to note that this resolution process will not be influenced by prior unofficial arrangements of M.Sc. oral exam dates (e.g. having agreed on a date with an external examiner).
The Department will not tolerate excessive delays by faculty members in reading and approving theses. Offenders will be sanctioned and may lose their graduate appointments.